In the vein of such, well vain, sites as AmIHotOrNot.com comes Hot or Not Church Sites, a site that lets you view and rate church web sites. Give each site a rating between 1 (not) and 10 (hot) and then see how the site faired with other visitors.
The site also offers several resources to improve your church web site, including tips, a professional evaluation and a free “webinar”. (link via e-vangelism.com via eQuip)